The most prestigious law school admissions discussion board in the world.
|
 |
 
|
Bold theory: college education is worthless because the US economy is broken
| https://imgur.com/a/o2g8xYK | 05/13/25 |
Poast new message in this thread
Date: May 13th, 2025 7:58 PM Author: https://imgur.com/a/o2g8xYK Okay, let's unpack this really important and complex issue. You're hitting on a core concern many people have – the rising cost of higher education in the US alongside a perception that the economic system isn't working for everyone. Here's a breakdown of why people are struggling to justify college costs and how it *could* be linked to broader economic problems, along with some counterarguments and nuances. I'll structure this into sections: **The Cost/Value Problem**, **Potential Economic Links**, **Other Factors at Play**, and **Possible Solutions**.
**1. The Cost/Value Problem (Why the Justification is Difficult)**
* **Rising Costs:** College tuition, fees, room, and board have increased dramatically over the past few decades, far outpacing inflation and wage growth. This isn't just about sticker price; it's about the total cost of attendance. * **Stagnant Wages (for many):** While some degrees still lead to high-paying jobs, wages for a significant portion of the workforce haven’t kept pace with rising costs of living, let alone college debt. A degree isn’t a guaranteed ticket to prosperity anymore. * **Debt Burden:** Student loan debt is enormous – over $1.7 trillion nationally. Many graduates are struggling to repay loans while also facing high housing costs, healthcare expenses, and other financial pressures. * **Return on Investment (ROI) Doubts:** The traditional narrative of "college = better job/higher salary" is being questioned. People are seeing: * Recent grads working in jobs that don't require a degree. * High unemployment or underemployment among college graduates in certain fields. * The rise of alternative education and training options (bootcamps, online courses) that promise skills for specific careers at lower cost. * **Perceived Lack of Value:** Some students question the relevance of their coursework to real-world jobs. They feel like they're paying a lot for an experience that isn’t preparing them effectively for the workforce.
**2. Potential Economic Links - How a "Broken" Economy Could Contribute**
You suggested the US economy might be "fundamentally broken," and there are arguments to support how economic trends exacerbate the college cost/value problem:
* **Income Inequality:** The widening gap between the rich and poor means that lower-income families face greater barriers to affording college, even with financial aid. The benefits of a college degree aren't evenly distributed; they disproportionately accrue to those already privileged. * **Wage Stagnation & Declining Labor Power:** Decades of policies (decline in unionization, globalization, automation) have weakened the bargaining power of workers. This contributes to wage stagnation and makes it harder for graduates to earn enough to justify student loan debt. * **Neoliberal Policies & Marketization of Education:** The shift towards treating higher education as a commodity – driven by market-based reforms – has led to increased competition among institutions, which can fuel cost inflation (e.g., lavish facilities to attract students). Reduced public funding for colleges shifted the burden onto students and families. * **Financialization:** The student loan industry itself is heavily financialized. Private lenders and servicers profit from student debt, creating incentives that may not align with borrowers’ best interests. * **Decline of Manufacturing & Shift to a Service/Knowledge Economy:** While a knowledge economy *can* be beneficial, it's also created more precarious employment for many. The jobs available might not offer the same stability and wages as traditional manufacturing roles. * **Automation & Technological Disruption:** The rapid pace of technological change raises concerns about whether degrees will remain valuable in the long run. Some skills become obsolete quickly, leading to uncertainty about career paths.
**3. Other Factors at Play (Beyond a "Broken" Economy)**
It's crucial to acknowledge factors *besides* broad economic trends:
* **Administrative Bloat:** Many colleges have seen significant increases in administrative staff and spending without a corresponding increase in faculty or student services. * **Endowment Management:** While some institutions use endowments effectively, others are criticized for not leveraging them sufficiently to reduce tuition costs. * **Demand-Driven Pricing:** Colleges can argue that they charge what the market will bear – if people are willing to pay high tuition and take on debt, institutions have less incentive to lower prices. This is related to the "marketization" point above. * **Lack of Transparency in Costs:** It’s often difficult for students and families to fully understand all costs associated with attending a particular college. * **Competition & Amenities Arms Race:** Colleges compete for students by offering increasingly luxurious facilities (state-of-the-art gyms, dorms), which drives up costs.
**4. Possible Solutions (Addressing Both College Costs & Economic Issues)**
Solving this problem requires tackling both the specific issues within higher education and the broader economic challenges:
* **Government Intervention:** * Increased public funding for colleges and universities to reduce reliance on tuition revenue. * Student loan debt forgiveness or reform (income-driven repayment plans, lower interest rates). * Regulation of the student loan industry to prevent predatory lending practices. * Investment in workforce development programs and apprenticeships as alternatives to traditional college. * **Institutional Reforms:** * Controlling administrative costs. * Increasing transparency in pricing and financial aid. * Focusing on providing value – relevant curriculum, career services, internships. * Exploring alternative educational models (online learning, competency-based education). * **Economic Policies:** * Raising the minimum wage to provide more economic security for graduates. * Strengthening unions and protecting workers' rights. * Addressing income inequality through progressive taxation and social safety nets. * Investing in infrastructure and creating jobs in growing industries.
**To conclude:** You’re right to question the cost of college, especially given current economic realities. While a "broken" economy isn't *solely* responsible for the problem, it certainly amplifies the pressures and makes it harder for many people to justify the investment. Addressing this requires systemic changes – both within higher education itself and in broader economic policies that promote greater equity and opportunity. |