Here's the thing about Mike Mussina
| light bossy elastic band | 01/22/19 | | wild motley den indirect expression | 01/22/19 | | Curious locus | 01/22/19 | | Fluffy Doctorate | 01/22/19 | | big fat ankles prole | 01/22/19 | | learning disabled home | 01/23/19 | | Fluffy Doctorate | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Blathering concupiscible lettuce | 01/23/19 | | learning disabled home | 01/23/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 01/23/19 | | Fluffy Doctorate | 01/23/19 | | Razzle-dazzle preventive strike casino | 01/23/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Fluffy Doctorate | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | tan vivacious university cuckoldry | 01/23/19 | | Fluffy Doctorate | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | learning disabled home | 01/23/19 | | aromatic french mad cow disease senate | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Galvanic puppy police squad | 01/23/19 | | Honey-headed gas station | 01/24/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Fluffy Doctorate | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | aromatic french mad cow disease senate | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | cobalt charismatic range party of the first part | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Galvanic puppy police squad | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Galvanic puppy police squad | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | embarrassed to the bone twinkling lay | 01/24/19 | | effete exhilarant station tattoo | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Razzle-dazzle preventive strike casino | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Razzle-dazzle preventive strike casino | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Blathering concupiscible lettuce | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | Razzle-dazzle preventive strike casino | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | aromatic french mad cow disease senate | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Fluffy Doctorate | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Fluffy Doctorate | 01/23/19 | | aromatic french mad cow disease senate | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Fluffy Doctorate | 01/23/19 | | Disgusting slate main people tank | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 07/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/25/19 | | Curious locus | 01/25/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/25/19 | | Curious locus | 01/25/19 | | titillating institution international law enforcement agency | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | cobalt charismatic range party of the first part | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | obsidian razzmatazz parlor potus | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | aromatic french mad cow disease senate | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | aromatic french mad cow disease senate | 01/23/19 | | Blathering concupiscible lettuce | 01/23/19 | | aromatic french mad cow disease senate | 01/23/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 07/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | aromatic french mad cow disease senate | 01/24/19 | | Curious locus | 01/24/19 | | pontificating supple faggotry | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | pontificating supple faggotry | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 01/23/19 | | Spruce Stage | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/23/19 | | cobalt charismatic range party of the first part | 01/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | wild motley den indirect expression | 01/24/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/24/19 | | Curious locus | 01/24/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/24/19 | | Fragrant french chef | 07/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 07/23/19 | | Chrome School Cafeteria | 01/24/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/23/19 | | Curious locus | 01/23/19 | | Flirting azn | 01/23/19 | | erotic trump supporter resort | 01/23/19 | | Disturbing bisexual mexican stead | 01/24/19 | | wild motley den indirect expression | 01/24/19 | | Curious locus | 01/24/19 | | wild motley den indirect expression | 01/24/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 01/24/19 | | Curious locus | 01/24/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 01/24/19 | | Curious locus | 01/24/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 01/24/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 01/24/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 01/24/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 07/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 01/24/19 | | burgundy jap | 07/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 07/23/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 07/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 07/23/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 02/07/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 07/16/19 | | soggy mentally impaired market | 07/23/19 | | burgundy jap | 07/23/19 | | Iridescent halford church | 07/23/19 | | light bossy elastic band | 04/05/20 |
Poast new message in this thread
Date: January 22nd, 2019 11:15 PM Author: light bossy elastic band
I'm a Moosemo I guess, but he really is a borderline case. Here are some Mussina factoids:
-Never won the Cy Young. Had seven top-five finishes. (Was runner-up once, in 1999; should have won it in 2001, when he finished fifth.)
-Never led the league in ERA, strikeouts, or WHIP. He led the league in wins once.
-Won 20 games only once (the last year of his career).
-Was nothing special in the postseason (7-8, 3.42).
-Spent much of his career among the top 20 pitchers in MLB, at times in the top 10, but was never regarded as a truly elite pitcher at any phase of his career.
He was sort of a rich man's Bert Blyleven, a very good pitcher who hung around, stayed healthy, and turned in solid seasons, year after year. Even with that effort, he only ended up with 270 wins. (To the poster who mentioned in the other thread that he played on bad Orioles teams-- this isn't really true. The Orioles in the mid-1990s were good. And all the Yankee teams he played on, except in 2008, made the playoffs.)
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37644518) |
Date: January 23rd, 2019 10:17 AM Author: Fluffy Doctorate
Meh, let’s move on to current pitchers hof chances. Top 10 by bwar.
Verlander - yes
Sabathia - yes
Kerahaw - yes
Greinke - yes, especially if he has a couple more good seasons
Hamels - no
Scherezer - yes, although would be interesting if he falls off cliff
King Félix - borderline - looks like he is done here, which won’t help his chances
Bartolo - no
Lester - no, but if pitches at level til 40 could get some traction.
Sale - on track for HOF
Degrom, Price, Kluber, Strasburg and Baumgarner could also be in the mix depending on how their careers go.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37646384) |
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 10:40 AM Author: Curious locus
CC is a NO
Felix is NO
Greinke NEEDS TO DO MORE
Strasburg and Price are gonna be NO, others we'll see.
Love Bartolo, Id vote for him even though he prob should be NO
Lester is def NO
Hoping OHTANI makes it to YES
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37646530) |
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 10:44 AM Author: Chrome School Cafeteria
If Mussina is in, CC is a borderline case (I know your egregious bahhhston fag schtick but cmon)
Greinke is close - again, a few more of above avg seasons and I think he makes it in, def not first ballot though
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37646547)
|
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 10:45 AM Author: Fluffy Doctorate
Yeah, didn’t realize Statsburg has only pitched 200 innings once - needs to step it up.
I want CC in because I don’t want to see articles for 10 years about whether he is being discriminated against for being a fat black alcoholic.
Hamels also has a better case than I realized; he had a decent 2018 (I missed it because it was split between two teams), so he might also put himself in the mix if he lasts to 40.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37646554) |
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 10:53 AM Author: Chrome School Cafeteria
The dude hit 92 mph at age 47 so yeah maybe
I don't really give a shit if they did roids tbh
Bonds and Clemens deserve to be in
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37646646) |
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 11:56 AM Author: Chrome School Cafeteria
Also insane - Curt Schilling not in b/c of politics
While Chipper JOnes, a Sandy Hook Truther, is in.
Like cmon if you're gonna be a shitlib faggot at least be consistent
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37647046) |
Date: January 23rd, 2019 10:25 AM Author: Fragrant french chef
He had 11 seasons in the AL top 10 in WAR for pitchers. He was basically a top 5-20 pitcher in baseball every year for ~15 years.
To put that in perspective:
- Ken Griffey Jr had 6 years in the top 10 of WAR for position players
- Derek JEter had 4 years
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37646433) |
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 10:43 AM Author: Curious locus
CREDITED
i doubt anyone ever dropped what they were doing and said "MUSSINA IS PITCHING TONIGHT, MUST WATCH"
When Pedro was on the mound, that was the case. Randy Johnson too.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37646544) |
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 10:48 AM Author: Chrome School Cafeteria
Maddux was the only one out of those 3 that was truly transcendental
Glavine & Smoltz would not have been first ballot HoFers had they not been part of that Braves staff
Also a shame that Maddux's best 2 years were cut short by the strike
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37646591) |
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 12:15 PM Author: Iridescent halford church
Correct.
The hall has always had 2 types of players.
You have the inner-hall type guys like Mays, Aaron, Ruth, Maddux, Seaver, Randy Johnson, Mickey Mantle, etc.
Then you have the outer-hall type guys like Jeff Bagwell, Tom Glavine, Robin Yount, Lou Brock, Roberto Alomar, Barry Larkin, Willie Stargell, Ryne Sandberg, hell even Nolan Ryan imo is outer hall.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37647164) |
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 11:32 AM Author: Fluffy Doctorate
(Rascist)
He was also past his peak by then.
Not saying he should be in, but more worthy than Baines.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37646872) |
|
Date: January 23rd, 2019 11:53 AM Author: Chrome School Cafeteria
Qatar has been surprisingly decent this tournament
Australia on the whole disappointing
It's between Iran & Japan at this point tbh unless Son goes on a fucking TEAR
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37647018) |
Date: January 23rd, 2019 11:56 AM Author: Iridescent halford church
I can't understand how everyone routinely underrates players who are close to the top for 15 years.
Mussina was one of the top starters in the league for 15 years. that as just as elite as someone who has 5 "transcendent" years and then some more average ones. people really underestimate how tough it is to be very very good over a long period of time. being very very good for 15 year IS elite, whether you like it or not.
as i've said before, in some respects a guy who is consistently very good is actually probably a more valuable player than a Cy Young level guy who plays at that level for 5 years and then drops off. it's extraordinarily beneficial for a team and a GM to rely on those very good guys, and you can structure your team around them. the stars who burn brighter for less time often lead to bad contracts and dead weight that causes a team to struggle.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37647040) |
Date: January 24th, 2019 6:30 AM Author: wild motley den indirect expression
here's the thing: defend the '92 and '01 cy young votes
also Ks are overrated. would rather my starter use his defense and get 3 outs throwing 10 pitches via weak grounders and soft pop ups than firing 20+ pitches to stikeout the side. moose was extremely effective at pitching to soft contact and an efficient innings eater, an underrated stat.
was also the maddux of the AL at fielding his position: 7x gg
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#37652496) |
|
Date: July 23rd, 2019 11:24 AM Author: Iridescent halford church
cr.
also, things like the CYA and the MVP are also largely dependent on your competition that year.
for me the question is whether a player had 1 or more seasons that were CYA or MVP level. If the answer is yes, then that counts for me.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4184391&forum_id=2#38575092) |
|
|