Rising insurance premiums, property taxes and maintenance costs show little sign of abating

Lori and Darren Gondry have seen their home insurance costs rise 63% in two years.

Lori and Darren Gondry have seen their home insurance costs rise 63% in two years. MORGAN HORNSBY FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

By Nicole Friedman

April 10, 2024 9:00 pm ET

Darren Gondry has owned his four-bedroom home near a golf course in Louisville, Ky., since 2004. He and his wife, Lori Gondry, paid off their primary mortgage in 2021.

That hasn’t stopped other bills associated with homeownership from piling up. Their home insurance costs have risen 63% in two years. Their property taxes, utility costs and homeowners’ association fees have risen in recent years, too.

“I was so sticker-shocked,” Gondry said of the mounting home-cost increases. “I fear they’re here to stay.”

Homeownership affordability fell to its lowest level since the 1980s last year as mortgage rates reached a 23-year high and home prices set new records.

Borrowing costs have eased somewhat this year, with the average rate for a 30-year home loan down about a percentage point since October. But other prices related to homeownership keep rising and show little sign of abating.

Property taxes and home-maintenance costs are climbing in much of the country. Non-mortgage costs including property taxes, maintenance, utilities and insurance make up more than half of homeowners’ overall costs, according to a 2022 analysis by Fannie Mae economists.

Insurance bills addressed to the Gondrys. PHOTO: MORGAN HORNSBY FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

Worst of all, home insurance premiums are soaring. Rates rose by more than 10% on average in 19 states in 2023 after a series of big payouts related to floods, storms, wildfires and other natural disasters across the U.S., according to an Insurance Information Institute analysis of data from S&P Global Market Intelligence. More Americans also moved to disaster-prone areas in recent years, increasing the exposure to these events.

Escalating costs on multiple fronts mean that many first-time buyers will continue to find homeownership a financial stretch.

Consumer prices rose 3.5% in March from a year earlier, the Labor Department said Wednesday. The stronger-than-expected inflation data could prompt Federal Reserve officials to hold rates at their current level for longer, which could also keep mortgage rates from declining.

The tens of millions of American homeowners who have locked in mortgage rates below 4% still have to contend with these other costs. And since insurance premiums, tax bills and maintenance costs can change each year, it’s hard for homeowners to budget how much more they will be paying even a few years from now.

YOUR MONEY BRIEFING

The Wall Street Journals Your Money Matters

How to Prepare For a Chaotic Homebuying Season

08:36

1x

SUBSCRIBE

Explore Audio Center

Skipping repairs

Plenty of homeowners are having to stretch financially to meet these home-related expenses. Nearly one in five said they couldn’t afford a $500 emergency repair without going into credit-card debt, according to a February online survey of 1,000 homeowners by tech company Clever Real Estate, while 42% said they’ve skipped home repairs or maintenance because of the cost.

Almost 10% of homeowners surveyed by Fannie Mae last year were not confident they could afford their home insurance premiums at their next renewal.

David Battany, executive vice president of capital markets at Guild Mortgage, said his late father’s homeownership expenses ballooned so much that he had to help him out financially.

His father’s Social Security income was $1,043 a month when he died in 2023. The property tax on his father’s Boulder, Colo., home was about $5,400 a year and his insurance costs had more than doubled between 2020 and 2023, to almost $7,000, Battany said.

David Battany with his father, Phillip Battany, in Boulder, Colo. PHOTO: PATRICE LANDAUER

All these escalating costs, Battany said, are going to be an unpleasant shock for many homeowners.

“This is not on their radar as a worry,” he said. “It’s sort of a hidden cost.”

Home-buying affordability fell last year to the lowest level since 1985, according to a National Association of Realtors index that factors in family incomes, mortgage rates and median single-family home prices. But the factors driving homeownership beyond the reach of many Americans have shifted dramatically from four decades ago.

Mortgage rates today have more than doubled from the lows of three years ago, but they are still modest compared with the 1980s. The Federal Reserve pushed up short-term rates aggressively starting in the late 1970s in an effort to halt inflation. In 1981, the average rate on a 30-year fixed mortgage topped 18%—nearly three times today’s rate.

As inflation came under control, mortgage rates came down. They dipped below 10% in 1986 and have remained in single digits since 1990.

During the early years of the pandemic, millions of Americans purchased homes or refinanced existing mortgages at historically low rates. The average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage fell below 3% several times in 2020 and 2021.

But even many of those homeowners who locked in record-low rates haven’t been able to dodge the other costs that continue to make homeownership less attainable for the typical American.

Home maintenance fees have risen. It cost an average of $6,663 a year to maintain a home in the fourth quarter of 2023, up 8.3% from a year earlier, according to home-improvement tech company Thumbtack. The index takes into account regular upkeep like gutter cleaning and lawn care along with occasional expenses like roof repair or maintenance.

Homes in Carpinteria, Calif. PHOTO: ANGELA OWENS/THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

Maintenance costs soared during the pandemic due to supply-chain issues and strong demand for renovations, said Marco Zappacosta, Thumbtack’s chief executive.

The pace of price increases has slowed, he said, but demand for home maintenance services continues to outpace the supply. Almost half of owner-occupied U.S. homes were built before 1980, and these buildings need maintenance as they age.

“There aren’t enough professionals to serve all these homeowners,” Zappacosta said. “It doesn’t seem like that is going to abate in the near term.”

In Manhattan, one of the country’s priciest real-estate markets, typical home values fell 8.9% in February from a year earlier, according to Zillow. But the monthly maintenance fees for recently sold co-ops rose 62% from the first quarter of 2020 to the first quarter of 2024, and condo fees rose 45% in the same period, according to appraisal firm Miller Samuel.

Property taxes, which are rising due to the effect of inflation on local government budgets, are also pushing homeowners to dig deeper into their bank accounts. The average property tax for U.S. single-family homes was $4,062 in 2023, up 4.1% from 2022, according to real-estate data firm Attom. Some major metro areas are contending with much bigger increases. In Charlotte, N.C., the average property tax rose 31.5% from 2022 to 2023. In Indianapolis it was up nearly 19%.

Surging home insurance costs are hitting homeowners hardest of all.

Some insurers have stopped offering coverage in some states, leaving homeowners with fewer options. Homeowners with mortgages—which is about 60% of all owners—are required to purchase property insurance. In some cases, homeowners without mortgages are opting to go without home insurance. They plan to self-insure or move away if a disaster strikes.

Catastrophic weather events, rising labor and material costs and uncertainty about future losses are all pushing up home insurance prices—even in states less prone to hurricanes and wildfires. The average annual home insurance cost rose about 20% between 2021 and 2023 to $2,377, according to insurance-shopping site Insurify, which projects another 6% increase in 2024.

It’s likely to be higher than that in several states. Insurify expects average home-insurance costs to rise by more than 10% in eight states this year, including Louisiana, Maine and Michigan.

“The insurance really is, I think, just as crippling, if not more so, than interest rates,” said real-estate agent Kara Breithaupt in New Orleans, where floods and hurricanes have caused insurance costs to rise faster than in most of the U.S.

A home in Barataria, La., after Hurricane Ida in 2021.

Brandon Bell/Getty

Destroyed homes after Hurricane Nicole in Daytona Beach, Fla., in 2022.

Ricardo Arduengo/AFP/Getty

Louisville, Colo., after the 2021 Marshall Fire.

Carl Glenn Payne/Zuma Press

“When you’re talking about a $500,000 property that has an $8,000 homeowners insurance premium and a $2,000 flood insurance premium, and property taxes on top of that, the carrying costs have exponentially increased,” Breithaupt said.

These higher costs have forced some homeowners to sell, she said, but good luck finding a buyer. The typical home in the New Orleans metro area that went under contract in February had been on the market for 97 days, the slowest of any major metro area, according to real-estate brokerage Redfin.

‘Two mortgages in one’

Steve Kissee listed two Louisiana houses for sale last year, an inherited property and a vacation home.

Two accepted offers for the inherited property fell through before closing. It finally sold in December but for about 17% below its initial listing price. Kissee said he had to offer the new owner a type of contract enabling the buyer to pay in installments, because the buyer couldn’t qualify for a traditional mortgage due to the insurance costs.

The vacation home, on Lake Catherine Island in New Orleans, has been sitting on the market since August with no offers. He said the price to insure it is a big reason why.

Kissee is also struggling with insurance costs for his primary home in New Orleans. He received a renewal quote for wind and hail insurance last year for about $31,000, up from a $3,200 premium the year before. He switched to the state’s insurer of last resort for about $7,900 after replacing his roof. His monthly payment for taxes and insurance is higher than the principal and interest payment on his mortgage, he said.

“It’s kind of like having two mortgages in one,” he said.

Insurers are also passing on more risk to consumers through higher deductibles, insurance agents say.

In Colorado, the 2021 Marshall Fire that swept through the suburbs between Denver and Boulder is still boosting insurance costs in that state. Insurance broker Michael McCarron said many of his clients’ home-insurance bills are rising 20% to 40% a year.

“Affordability was always a problem—an increasing problem in the last three or four years—but now it’s truly an availability problem,” said McCarron, owner of Lakeside Insurance in Arvada, Colo.

Price increases could slow in 2025, he said, but he doesn’t expect insurance costs to return to where they stood before the fire.

“This is the new normal,” he said.

Darren Gondry with his dogs outside of his home in Louisville. PHOTO: MORGAN HORNSBY FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

Write to Nicole Friedman at nicole.friedman@wsj.com

We Want to Hear From You

Have you bought or sold a home recently or are you in the process of buying or selling one? What was the experience like?*

How have mortgage-interest rates or other costs, such as home insurance and property taxes, influenced your decision to buy or sell? What about the inventory of homes for sale in your area?*

Where did you purchase or sell your home (city, state)?*

What is your mortgage rate?

Name*

Email*

By submitting your response to this questionnaire, you consent to Dow Jones processing your special categories of personal information and are indicating that your answers may be investigated and published by The Wall Street Journal and you are willing to be contacted by a Journal reporter to discuss your answers further. In an article on this subject, the Journal will not attribute your answers to you by name unless a reporter contacts you and you provide that consent.

Copyright ©2024 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

HIDE CONVERSATION (1570)

Conversation1.6K Comments

By joining the conversation you are accepting our community rules and terms. To view rules, terms and FAQs, click here. Questions can be sent to moderator@wsj.com.

Conversations on news articles and news columns must be kept on the topic of the story. In opinion content, conversations can delve into other subjects. The conversation will close on this article four days after publication.

What do you think?

2 People typing

Sort by

Newest

Jack Armstrong

6 minutes ago

Newly minted RTrolls are all over the WSJ. All trying to win that microwave oven.

Reply

·

·

Share

DE

Dave Edwards

1 minute ago

Eh? Are you saying this is not a valid story - because to most of us it certainly is valid. And we are seeing annnual inflation well north of 4% in our housing costs.

Reply

·

·

Share

FS

frank storck

9 minutes ago

Good you posted this regular Americans are very intently aware of this. Its the dead head leaders and Ivory tower Types that read this paper that read this paper but dont really care though.

Reply

·

1

·

Share

DE

Dave Edwards

5 minutes ago

And I have a feeling this reality - together with grocery and travel costs - is the reason that we don’t believe it when Biden and his lackeys tell us how well they are doing on inflation. So clearly we are deluded……

Reply

·

·

Share

ET

Elle TACK

12 minutes ago

Cheap mortgage money bought a lot of homes, esp cheap FHA $ but also bank $$$ at 2.3%….people view that as Great but it was monopoly $ compared to the Overall cost of Owning a home.

Sure, insurance is high but so is all around Home Maintenance (roofs, electrical, HVAC, lawns, trees, sewers, painting, appliances, etc)

Too many people haven’t realized the complete Cost of Home Ownership…more info should be published on the TOC of Biggest Purchase of most people’s lives.

(Edited)

Reply

·

·

Share

DM

David Masters

13 minutes ago

I have had a severe disability my entire life and a wheelchair user. I worked through unimaginable hardships to make a way for myself and my wife, but now, we are having to sell our home because my retirement income can't keep pace. It is sad to have a paid for home and still can't afford to stay in it. Three or four years ago we were doing ok, but our home insurance rates have gone from $900 to $4500, our auto insurance from $1400 yearly to $5400 yearly and property tax has tripled. On top of all those increases come needed home repairs—we have a leaking roof, food costs and the cost of medi...

See more

Reply

·

3

·

Share

SJ

SANFORD M JOHNSON

19 minutes ago

Unfortunately the net impact of this is a narrowing of the "middle class". Think standard of living.

Reply

·

3

·

Share

GW

George Woodruff

20 minutes ago

Just wait until all these 4-6,000 square foot homes need to have new roof shingles. Folks have no idea what they're in for.

(Edited)

Reply

·

6

·

Share

AM

Andrew McColl

20 minutes ago

If you did not purchase your home before 2020 or at least locked in your dandy 30-year mortgage at 2.5% like the fortunate class, you are forever a loser. Too bad, so sad Gen-Z.

-From one P*ssed-Off Gen-Z who just came of age to buy a home

Reply

·

2

·

Share

AC

Alec C

6 minutes ago

My grandpa worker as a butcher, didn't own the shop just worked there, and raised his family of 5 kids in a 6 bedroom house. My grandma didn't work. Today, I work in private equity my wife works in healthcare and we can't afford to buy a house with 4 bedrooms to start a family. We can thank our egregious fiscal spending, that has a total disregard for the American people.

Reply

·

·

Share

JW

Jimmy Watson

1 minute ago

Supply demand.

"grandpa time" had much smaller population, and US was about the same size (and less hurricanes if you believe it).

Most advanced countries, sans Canada, US, and Australia, have much less sf/person. So, the "shrinkage" is normal.

Plus location, location. Go to west Texas or NM, surely a private equity salary can buy a ranch.

Reply

·

·

Share

SH

Sharon Hannon

7 minutes ago

When I was about your age, interest rates were 18%. I lived long enough to see them drop to almost zero. Maybe you will too. But weather-related disasters and high insurance costs are here to stay ... for all of us.

Reply

·

·

Share

DB

Don Brown

21 minutes ago

In addition to taxes, insurance, and maintenance, another area that should be referenced is the age of the home and its relative cost in energy and maintenance.

Our energy costs went down considerably in a newer energy efficient home. We have also learned that when you have a home that is over 10 years old, you are going to have to replace lots of mechanical items and potentially upgrade old plumbing and electrical items. It all factors into the TCO - and any number of HGTV home remodeling shows.

Btw, just because you can buy a house in a specific area doesn’t mean that it is a good idea - or...

See more

Reply

·

2

·

Share

PK

Peter Kranzler

8 minutes ago

I once read that insulating your home has triple the yield of buying a Treasury note.

Obviously where you live is a big variable but it's an interesting concept.

Reply

·

1

·

Share

RB

robert both

15 minutes ago

Also, the very new mass production construction doesn't have any appeal. The houses are cookie cutters with no personality.

Reply

·

1

·

Share

Show 1 more reply

Gary J. Rhine

22 minutes ago

paid off their primary mortgage in 2021

Probably paid off a low interest rate. Bad move.

Reply

·

2

·

Share

RB

robert both

14 minutes ago

Any mortgage designed to keep you poor.

Reply

·

·

Share

RB

robert both

14 minutes ago

Paying off mortgage is never a bad move.

Reply

·

1

·

Share

1 reply

CR

C Roy

24 minutes ago

Can we discuss how ludicrous the David Battany anecdote is?

His father lived in his own home in Boulder and can't afford the $12k/yr in taxes and insurance on his $12k/yr social security benefit?

Certainly his father never relied on his $12k/yr benefit to live on in Boulder, regardless of recent increases in home ownership costs.

Reply

·

2

·

Share

ET

Elle TACK

9 minutes ago

Boulder was expensive the entirety of last 40 years lived there….it hasn’t been cheap ever but certainly all knew that if one lived under the “golden Boulder umbrella”, your home was an excellent but expensive asset.

(Edited)

Reply

·

1

·

Share

RB

robert both

12 minutes ago

Certainly he had another income when he was younger.

Reply

·

·

Share

https://archive.is/VjUpn

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5520290&forum_id=2Reputation#47601197)

Consider yourself lucky, shitlennial fags!

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5520290&forum_id=2Reputation#47601452)